CUTI JUMAAT

CUTI JUMAAT

2/4/10

Kelemahan kereta kebal PT91, Utusan dikritik



Antara komen dalam Blog beliau ialah :

Artikel berkenaan kereta kebal sepatutnya ditulis oleh pegawai tentera yang berkaitan, bukan oleh orang awam yang tidak tahu membezakan antara kereta kebal dan kereta perisai.

Kereta kebal PT 91M sama macam model sebelumnya T 72 yang tewas teruk semasa Perang Teluk oleh kereta kebal US M1A1 dan British Challenger 2.

Kereta perisai yang terbaik ATM ada ialah jenis Ferret. Yang lainnya, yang dibeli sejak 1970an banyak masalah.

Kereta kebal PT 91M gagal sama sekali (total failure) sejak mula berkhidmat dengan ATM, masalah utama ialah sistem gear.

Masalah PT 91M ini bertambah teruk lagi apabila dimasukkan sistem dari negara lain selain Poland, ini menyukarkan krew penyenggaraan dan meningkatkan kos penyenggaraan.

Diramalkan PT 91M ini tidak mampu beroperasi selepas 10 tahun, dimana akhirnya akan menjadi sasaran tembakan latihan di Asahan.

*******************************************

the Malaysian Army has had in its inventory is the Ferret Scout car. All other armoured vehicles purchased since the 70’s are a total flop”.

He went on to say that the PT 91M is a total failure even before it entered service in the Malaysian Army; the major mechanical glitch being the gearing system.

And what is even worse is that the Malaysian Army has incorporated a number of foreign manufactured systems (other than Polish) into the tank, and this makes the maintenance of the tank a nightmare for the maintenance crew; besides the exorbitant cost that the army has to bear to maintain these systems.

He does not foresee the PT 91M being operational worthy after 10 years of service; where it will finally end up as targets at Asahan Range.

If this posting is deemed critical to the army’s acquisition of the PT 91M, I wish to be corrected by those who are physically handling the tank; in this instant officers of the Armoured Corps, and not by some civilian writers who don’t even know the difference between a tank and an Armoured Personnal Carrier.

Sumber http://mindnoevil.blogspot.com/2010/02/pt-91m-main-battle-tank-was-it-worthy.html

********************************

Utusan Malaysia 26 Jan 2010

Pendekar PT-91M: Igauan kepada musuh negara

Oleh MOHD. ASRON MUSTAPHA

mohdasron.mustapha@utusan.com.my

Sumber : http://www.utusan.com.my/utusan/info.asp?y=2010&dt=0126&pub=utusan_malaysia&sec=Polis_%26_Tentera&pg=te_01.htm&arc=hive

No comments: